Why Good Intentions Aren't Enough in App Security

The Tea app was designed to be a safe space for women to connect, share experiences, and protect themselves from dangerous men in the dating world. However, when the Tea app was hacked, the opposite effect happened. The very men that the app was designed to protect women from were now using their images and conversations against them.

The app’s data breach highlights the risks of rushing development, overrelying on AI, and neglecting security practices. Ultimately, this incident is an important reminder for developers that building user trust requires more than just intent. Security, transparency, and rigor must be built into the ethos from day one of development.

‍

Understanding the Tea App Data Breach

Tea is a support and community app for women to vet potential dating partners through background checks, catfish detection, red flag alerts, and sex offender registries. In late July, the app released a statement confirming that they had suffered a significant data breach. 

Around 72,000 images, including approximately 13,000 selfies and government IDs were exposed. The incident also compromised over 1 million private messages containing sensitive and personal information, such as phone numbers, names, and social media handles.

According to 404 Media, who first reported the incident, hackers from the 4chan message board gained unauthorized access through Tea’s legacy storage system via an exposed database hosted on Google’s mobile app development platform. The breach is significant because it endangered women in vulnerable situations.

The hackers posted the women’s photos across 4chan and X (formerly Twitter) for ridicule and harassment. They even created ranking websites and used image metadata to track women’s locations. Particularly for survivors of intimate partner violence, this breach presents real danger.

Tea responded by suspending their direct messaging feature, launching an FBI investigation, and offering free identity protection services to all the women affected. Overall, this incident raises important questions about how we evaluate and prioritize security in apps designed to protect vulnerable communities.

‍

The Role of AI and Vibe Coding

As trusting AI, chatbots, and apps, in general, become more commonplace, the process of sharing sensitive information carries more risk. One emerging issue is vibe coding. Vibe coding refers to when developers use AI to write their code. Though it’s unconfirmed that Tea relied on AI for coding, vibe coding is becoming a hot topic in today’s app development landscape.

There are many risks of vibe coding, including:

• Security: The lack of human review can lead to security issues, such as insecure coding practices, outdated libraries, or missing input validation.
• Maintainability: Coding can be difficult to maintain over time if there’s no clear intent or documentation behind AI-generated decisions.
• Scalability: AI-generated code might not be designed with future growth in mind, creating performance issues as user bases expand.
• User experience: AI code can prioritize functionality over UX, creating interfaces that work technically but are difficult or confusing for users to navigate.
• Data leakage: There’s always a risk of accidentally exposing customer data or secrets that could be embedded in AI-generated code.

Whether or not the Tea app relied heavily on vibe coding, this discussion matters for any startup or established company using AI in their development process. It’s a reminder that rapid development can’t come at the expense of user safety and security.

‍

Comfortability with AI Chatbots

Another emerging trend alongside AI’s rise is that people are becoming more comfortable confiding in AI rather than humans, specifically with sensitive personal information. The accessibility of AI chatbots is a huge factor, as they are mostly free and available 24/7. This is an attractive alternative for people who don’t have access or the means to go to professional therapy.

The problem is that most chatbots aren't specifically designed with the level of encryption and data handling protocols needed for highly sensitive personal information. They also don’t have the capability to respond appropriately to crisis situations compared to trained human professionals. While AI can be helpful in many contexts, these systems are not equipped to provide life-saving interventions like crisis hotlines or licensed counselors can.

In Tea’s case, the consequences of the data breach were particularly devastating because the app serves a portion of women already in vulnerable situations. Survivors of abuse, those seeking support, and women sharing deeply personal experiences were exposed.

‍

Security Challenges for AI-App Development

Beyond vibe coding and increased comfort with AI, several other security challenges exist, including:

• Documentation gaps: Security audits are more difficult when AI generates code with poor or missing documentation. 
• Data pipeline vulnerabilities: AI-powered data processing systems usually handle large amounts of personal information, creating more opportunities for data leakage or unauthorized reuse.
• Overreliance on speed and iteration: The speed-first culture emphasizes rapid development and deployment, which can prevent building comprehensive and robust privacy protections.
• Integration flaws: Security issues may not surface until after deployment if AI assists in creating system components, like APIs or authentication flows.

Overall, it’s clear that AI is a powerful tool for developers. However, it should not be utilized as a substitute for secure engineering practices and development processes. The goal is to use it responsibly within a framework that prioritizes user safety and data protection.

The Tea app data breach is just one example of how a slip in security and privacy can affect millions of users. Whether or not AI coding played a role in Tea’s specific vulnerabilities, the app incorporates AI features (such as face recognition and reverse image search) into its platform, making these broader challenges relevant for any team building AI-enhanced apps.

‍

Takeaways for Developers

The Tea data breach shows that good intentions are not enough in app development, specifically when building platforms for vulnerable communities. It highlights important lessons for developers and founders:

• Build security considerations into the development process from day one
• Extensively audit any AI-generated code
• Adopt a privacy-first design
• Test continuously

App development is already set up for success when trust and security are treated as core features, not just afterthoughts. And while AI accelerates innovation, without comprehensive security practices in place, it also accelerates risk. The cost of losing user trust and damaging your platform’s reputation highly outweighs the cost of building securely.